The Department of Health and Human Services has finalized a rule that removes federal wage and benefit mandates from the standards every Head Start program must meet, undoing the most expensive parts of a 2024 regulation. The department's Administration for Children and Families estimates the change will save programs more than $2 billion in future costs. The rule appears in the Nov. 16 Federal Register and takes effect Jan. 15, 2027.
The 2024 rule, finalized under President Joe Biden, required Head Start programs with more than 200 slots to raise teacher pay by 2031 to match what local school districts pay public preschool teachers, or 90 percent of local kindergarten teacher pay where no public preschool exists, Education Week reported. It also directed programs to set pay scales for all staff, pay every employee enough to cover basic living costs and provide specified benefits. The new rule strikes those requirements. The administration believes they are not in line with the plain language of the Head Start Act and are "costly and overly prescriptive for Head Start programs and staff," the agency said in the final rule.
Much of the administration's case rests on enrollment. When the Biden administration adopted the mandates, it acknowledged that without enough new money from Congress, some programs would have to cut funded slots to pay for raises, and it projected that funded enrollment could fall by more than 100,000 slots by 2031. That rule let federal officials waive the requirements if Head Start funding did not rise by more than 1.3 percent by 2028, according to Education Week. The final rule puts the figure at about 106,000 funded slots that programs would have had to eliminate to comply without additional appropriations. "This rule removes a burdensome unfunded mandate that would impact programs' ability to continue operating at current levels and would have necessitated laying off staff," the agency wrote.
Head Start, created in 1965 as part of the War on Poverty, serves children up to age 5 from low-income families. Its roughly $12 billion annual budget has paid for about 700,000 slots in recent years. HHS estimated in 2024 that the pay requirements would raise the average Head Start teacher's salary by about $10,000. Average teacher pay in the program ranges from $26,964 in Mississippi to $79,853 in the District of Columbia, according to a 2024 Urban Institute brief cited by K-12 Dive.
The administration proposed the rollback in May and received nearly 300 public comments. Some praised the added flexibility and the end of an unfunded mandate. Many others objected, among them two letters signed by multiple members of Congress, raising concerns about workforce stability, pay equity with public schools and support for teachers.
In its response, the agency was explicit about what the rule leaves alone. It does not require or encourage programs to cut current wages, programs that have already given raises do not have to reverse them, and a program that decides higher pay is needed to keep its staff can still provide it within its budget. "This final rule reflects trust in Head Start program leaders to run their programs, value staff, and make decisions on staff compensation given the local context and on their own timeline," the agency wrote.
The agency also acknowledged that the reversal comes after some programs had started to comply, including by asking to reduce their funded enrollment, and that some employees may have stayed in their jobs expecting raises. It said it was acting years before the 2031 deadline so programs would not make further changes for requirements that will no longer apply. It weighed alternatives, including a longer implementation timeline, and concluded that a delay would not resolve its concern that prescriptive federal pay rules limit local flexibility and could force enrollment cuts.
Early childhood organizations criticized the decision. The National Head Start Association said underfunding is straining programs' ability to pay competitively while keeping enrollment steady, and that dropping the federal requirements "does not change competitive pressures or eliminate the staffing shortages that continue to limit some programs' ability to open classrooms and serve more eligible children and families," K-12 Dive reported. "A strong Head Start program depends on a stable, qualified workforce, and programs must have the resources necessary to recruit, retain, and support the professionals who serve children and families every day," said Yasmina Vinci, the association's executive director. The National Association for the Education of Young Children said, "HHS frames this as a choice between paying educators and serving children, but a funded slot without a qualified teacher serves no one."
The 2024 rule followed a period of heavy staff turnover. In October 2023, 15 percent of Head Start staff positions were vacant, according to a National Head Start Association survey cited by Education Week. Urban Institute and National Education Association figures cited by the publication put average Head Start teacher pay below $40,000 in recent years, compared with more than $70,000 for the average public school teacher.
The pay rollback is one part of a broader effort by the administration to overhaul the program. A separate HHS proposal to loosen other Head Start standards, including requirements for low student-teacher ratios, family support services and comprehensive health screenings, is still pending, Education Week reported. The department has described that plan, too, as a way to give programs more flexibility and expand access.