The Labor Department on Monday released a proposed rewrite of the rules for employer-sponsored green cards that would make companies search longer for American applicants, bar filings from employers that recently laid off U.S. workers in the same jobs, and end a long-standing exemption that lets employers sponsor foreign nurses and physical therapists without first testing the domestic labor market.
The notice of proposed rulemaking runs 350 pages. It was filed for public inspection Monday morning and is scheduled to appear in the Federal Register on Tuesday. It covers PERM, the labor certification process most employers must complete before sponsoring a foreign worker for an EB-2 or EB-3 green card. To certify a job, the department must find that there are not enough able, willing, qualified and available U.S. workers to fill it and that hiring the foreign worker will not hurt the wages and working conditions of Americans in similar positions.
The department wrote that it has not revised the PERM rules in nearly 20 years, and its news release called the package the "first comprehensive set of regulatory reforms" to the program in that span, Newsweek reported. Erickson Immigration Group, a corporate immigration law firm, said in a client alert that the plan is the most significant PERM reform in nearly two decades.
The department also proposes to stop administering Schedule A, a list that lets employers skip the labor market test entirely for two groups: professional nurses and physical therapists, and foreign nationals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts. In the proposal, the department argued that federal immigration law gives it no authority to exempt any occupation from the test Congress required, and that even if it had that power, it "can no longer confirm that a nationwide shortage of workers exists" to justify keeping those jobs on the list. A request for information drew more than 2,000 comments, the department said, and none supplied a reliable way to decide which occupations belong there.
The change would reach a sizable stream of cases. The department's economic analysis counts an average of 23,835 Schedule A applications filed each year with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services in fiscal years 2023 through 2025, compared with about 108,786 certified PERM applications a year. Employers hiring in those occupations would have to run the full recruitment process instead.
Recruitment would change for everyone else, too. Under the current rules, an employer generally places a 30-day job order with a state workforce agency and buys print newspaper advertisements on two Sundays. The proposal would require each recruitment method to stay active for at least 90 calendar days, or longer if the employer customarily advertises similar jobs for a longer stretch, and would replace the newspaper requirement with electronic recruiting through company websites, commercial job boards, social media and job fairs. The department estimated that dropping mandatory newspaper ads would save employers about $164 million a year, according to Newsweek.
Companies that cut American staff would face a much longer wait. Today, a layoff in the area of intended employment within six months of filing obliges an employer to notify and consider the laid-off workers. Under the proposal, an employer that laid off U.S. workers in the same or a similar occupation and area of employment during the previous two years would be barred from filing. The department wrote that a shorter restriction can be avoided "simply by delaying the filing of an application" and that a two-year period "would provide a more meaningful safeguard." The protections would extend to workers let go by employers that rely on third-party staffing companies, and employers would have to meet new standards for reporting layoffs.
Other provisions would limit each certification to a single initial I-140 petition, ending what the department described as a practice of reusing certifications based on a mistaken reading of the rules. The plan would also expand employer attestations, audits, revocations and debarment, and it would move filing and correspondence fully online. The department is considering whether fully remote jobs should qualify at all and is seeking comment on excluding them, although the proposal as written does not exclude them.
"American Workers are the best in the world, and they deserve the first and best job opportunities," Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling said in a statement quoted by Newsweek. "Existing regulations have instead allowed companies to sponsor foreign workers without fully considering American workers first." He said the change would "ensure American workers are first in line for high-skilled, high-paying job opportunities over foreign labor."
The proposal follows increased federal scrutiny of employers that use the program. Vice President JD Vance said in October that several companies would be suspended from PERM over alleged fraud, and the Justice Department has reached settlements with employers over alleged discrimination against U.S. workers in PERM recruitment, according to Newsweek's report.
Some immigration practitioners warned of the cost to employers. Adam Klein, a former senior Homeland Security Department official, told Newsweek that the two-year layoff bar "could have far-reaching implications, particularly for technology companies and other employers that regularly restructure." "This is more than an administrative burden; it could prevent an employer from pursuing sponsorship altogether," he said. He added that ending Schedule A would add "time, expense, and uncertainty" for employers sponsoring those workers. "Given the staffing challenges facing healthcare employers, this could have consequences well beyond immigration processing," he said. Erickson Immigration Group called the plan "a lengthy and highly consequential proposal" that could significantly affect employers sponsoring foreign nationals.
None of it is in force yet. The proposal does not change current green card requirements, and the department is taking public comments for 60 days after Tuesday's publication. Klein noted that its real effect will depend on what the department ultimately finalizes and how it administers the new requirements.