The Senate on Monday confirmed Daniel D. Domenico, President Donald Trump's nominee for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, voting 51-46 to give the Colorado federal trial judge a lifetime seat on the Denver-based court.

The official roll call split strictly by party. Every vote in favor came from a Republican, and every vote against came from a Democrat or one of the chamber's two independents. Two Republicans and one Democrat did not vote.

The Tenth Circuit takes appeals in federal cases from Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming. Domenico will succeed Judge Timothy M. Tymkovich, an appointee of President George W. Bush who is taking senior status, a form of semi-retirement, Colorado Politics reported. The court's clerk did not immediately say when Domenico will be sworn in.

He is the only judge Trump has named to the Tenth Circuit in his second term and the third across both of his terms, joining Judges Allison H. Eid of Colorado and Joel M. Carson III of New Mexico. Seven of the court's 12 full-time judges were appointed by Democratic presidents and five by Republicans, and Domenico fills a seat held by a Republican appointee.

Domenico once clerked for Tymkovich, the judge he is now replacing. He went on to serve as Colorado's solicitor general under Republican Attorney General John Suthers, argued two cases before the U.S. Supreme Court and moved into private practice in 2015. During Trump's first term he was interested in the appeals court vacancy left when Neil Gorsuch joined the Supreme Court, but Trump instead nominated him to the district court. He took that bench in 2019 as the president's only first-term appointee to Colorado's federal trial court. He is a graduate of Georgetown University and the University of Virginia's law school.

As a trial judge he handled a number of politically significant cases, several of them involving religious institutions. He barred Colorado from enforcing its ban on so-called abortion reversal treatment against a Catholic health clinic, and he ordered the state to admit a Christian preschool to its universal pre-kindergarten program even though the school's policies conflicted with state non-discrimination requirements. Early in the COVID-19 pandemic he exempted two Denver-area churches from some public health restrictions, and in a separate case he allowed a Castle Rock church to sidestep local zoning rules on religious grounds.

Colorado's two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, voted no. After his Judiciary Committee hearing in June, they said they had concerns about his support for the government's expansive view of its immigration detention authority and about his refusal to acknowledge that Trump lost the 2020 presidential election, according to Colorado Politics.

The detention question had already reached his courtroom. Earlier this year Domenico became the only federal judge in Colorado to rule that the government could hold people in immigration custody without a bond hearing even after they had lived in the country for years. The Tenth Circuit, the court he is now joining, ruled shortly afterward that the government had misread its authority.

His promotion opens a seat on a trial court that is already stretched. Amid a sharp rise in immigration detentions, the district is receiving roughly 100 petitions a week from people challenging their confinement, an influx that has about doubled its caseload within months. The court's clerk, Jeffrey P. Colwell, said it needs more full-time judges to keep pace and is weighing temporary options in the meantime.

Domenico served briefly as the district's chief judge this year before stepping aside from that role in early October in anticipation of his confirmation. Home-state senators traditionally hold considerable sway over district court nominations. A spokesperson for Hickenlooper said his office had not decided how it would approach the opening, and Bennet's office did not respond to questions from Colorado Politics.